Risk Handling (Oral Communications)

Tracks
Arrábida Room
Thursday, May 18, 2023
4:30 PM - 6:00 PM
Oral Communications

Speaker

Agenda Item Image
Alan Ager
USDA Forest Service Missoula Fire Sciences Lab

Chair

Biography

Alan Ager is Emeritus Scientist at the USDA Forest Service Fire Sciences Laboratory in Missoula Montana. He received his PhD in 1987 from the University of Washington and began his career with the Forest Service in 1989 as a landscape planner. His recent research has focused on scenario modeling of future forest and fuel management scenarios and the impact of extreme wildfire events. Ager and his team also work on spatial optimization methods to analyze ecological and economic tradeoffs in forest restoration and risk reduction programs. Ager’s team used their scenario modelling platform to develop a 10-year fuel treatment prioritization plan for the US that was the genesis of the national 2022 Wildfire Crisis Strategy. Ager has collaborated on wildfire related research with scientists from Argentina, Greece, Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Ukraine. His current affiliations include courtesy faculty appointments at Oregon State University and Portland State University, Professor at the University of Lisbon, and science advisor to Wildfires.org and Vibrant Planet LLC.
Agenda Item Image
Prof. Luigi Boschetti
University of Idaho

OC69 - The MODIS Fire Satellite Products: a multidecadal baseline for global fire activity and fire regimes

Abstract

NASA’s Terra and Aqua satellites enabled, for the first time, systematic production of high quality, multi-year, global 1 km active fire and 500-m burned area maps using observations from the Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). The 20-year NASA MODIS fire product record is the only science quality, reprocessed record of global fire activity, and plays a fundamental role in understanding the spatiotemporal drivers of fire activity and for emissions estimation and the relationship between climate and fire.
This presentation will focus on:
- The current state of the MODIS active fire and burned area products, and on the planned transition to the VIIRS instrument in order to provide the first ever global fire record covering the 30-year period conventionally required for climate analysis
- The use of the MODIS fire products to support national to continental level fire assessment and reporting, with particular regards to the tools developed available in the Global Wildfire Information System (GWIS).
We will illustrate the use of documented, transparent and reproducible methods for the derivation of summary statistics for supporting analysts and policy makers for the analysis of historical data, for the detection of anomalies in timing and intensity of the fire season, and for compiling summary reports and emission inventories.

Biography

Luigi Boschetti is a Professor of Remote Sensing in the College of Natural Resources at the University of Idaho. He was a Visiting Scientist with the Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich, UK (2000-2002), a Research Fellow with the EC-Joint Research Center, Ispra, Italy (2002-2004) , a Research Fellow with CNR-IREA, Milano, Italy, (2004 - 2005), and a Research Professor with the Department of Geographical Sciences, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA, (2005-2012). His research primarily involves the use of satellite data for global environmental monitoring, with a focus on the generation of fire monitoring products.
Agenda Item Image
Jonathan Boucher
Canadian Forest Service

OC70 - Integration of residential structures loss functions into wildfire risk assessment

Abstract

Understanding wildfire impacts on structures in wildland urban interface (WUI) communities is fundamental for emergency response and mitigation planning to reduce potential social and economic losses. The magnitude of structures loss determines the direct economic costs for re-building, indirect economic losses due to evacuation and disruption of economic activities as well as shelter needs. Here we will present a framework for the development and implementation of wildfire impact assessment of WUI residential structures for both deterministic incident-level and probabilistic community or regional scale analysis. The framework is made of the following successive components: hazard, inventory, exposure, and impact. The hazard model generates spatial and temporal distribution of fire intensity for wildfire event scenarios; the inventory model provides spatial pattern of exposed structures; the exposure model estimates the fire intensity at WUI locations; and the impact model evaluates the structures loss. This last component is done by applying newly developed empirical response functions represented as the relationship between fire intensity, distance from forest edge, resulting in expected proportion of burned structures. Risk analyses using this framework are synthesized into a number of impact indicators that will be showcased through two case studies using both deterministic and probabilistic based approaches.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Jonathan Boucher is a research scientist of the Canadian Forest Service developing science to support wildfire management and risk assessment activities. At the national level, he is a member of both the Science and Operation Committee of the Forest Mapping for Wildfire Resilience program, and a member of the Steering Committee for the National Wildland Fire Risk Framework for Canada. He is also part of the Fire Danger Group working at developing the Next-Generation Canadian Forest Fire Danger Rating System, where he leads the fuel component. He steers the Firehawk project, a web-based rapid risk evaluator for wildfires in Canada.
Agenda Item Image
Dr Sofia Karma
National Technical University of Athens

OC71 - Inclusive Community Engagement in Disaster Preparedness and Response focusing on wildfires and the generated smoke: Best practices and lessons learned

Abstract

The intensified weather events recorded on a global basis have been correlated with the so-called “climate crisis”; prolonged droughts, extremely high temperatures and heat waves usually result in destructive wildfires and huge quantities of smoke that may cross the borders with the respective impacts on the exposed populations.
Objectives:
1.To tackle the importance of inclusive community engagement in disaster preparedness and response for reducing vulnerabilities according to the Sendai Framework goals, focusing on wildfires and the generated smoke.
2. To highlight the significance of running tabletop exercises or simulated drills with groups that may be considered vulnerable in disasters, like people with disabilities, or children for standardization of procedures.
Methods:
Best practices and lessons learned on how locally-led action with inclusive criteria may strengthen communities’ disaster resilience upon emerging risks in reference to international experiences, are gathered and presented here; experiences based on the research prepared so far by the European Center for Forest Fires of the EUR-OPA Major Hazards Agreement, will also be shared.
Results: Community-level disaster risk management could be proved a critical element for the training of communities at risk to cope with emergencies, leaving no one behind; possible synergisms and interconnections among the key players will be discussed.
Conclusions:
Empowerment of a people-centred approach and active involvement of citizens with no discrimination in disaster preparedness and response activities may reinforce communities’ resilience in a more sustainable manner; the combination of a bottom-up with a top-down approach could be considered in disaster risk governance.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Sofia Karma is Dr. Chemical Engineer and Teaching Laboratory Staff at the National Technical University of Athens, Greece. She is active for over 15 years on the field of advanced chemical sensors and state-of -the art analytical methods for health, safety and environmental applications. She is consultant at the Europa Major Hazards Agreement in the area of Disaster Risk Reduction and research associate of the European Center for Forest Fires, Council of Europe. Her research encompasses forest fires and smoke impact assessment on the population focusing on vulnerable groups, fire safety engineering, disaster resilience and inclusive disaster risk management.
Agenda Item Image
Joe Harris
USDA Forest Service

OC72 - The Evolution of the Accident Review Process within the USDA Forest Service

Abstract

Objective: To describe the evolution of accident reviews within the USDA Forest Service.

Methods: A case study in how an organization went from focusing on the pointy end operator in the aftermath of an accident, to focusing on a systems approach with an emphasis on organizational learning as a means of preventing accidents.

Results: The Forest Service went from blaming pointy end operators as a means of preventing accidents to focusing on the system of work to prevent accidents. This entailed setting the stage for those who were present during an accident to tell their accounts of what happened so that the organizational leadership could suss out the conditions and pressures present at the time of the accident. Once the organization has a better understanding of the conditions of the accident, they are better positioned to make up-stream changes to the system of work so that the people on the ground are better supported by the agency. This then grew into a metareview effort that took into account 10 years worth of accidents that focused on relieving pressure up-stream in the organizational system of work. This metareview captures themes to focus on into the future to set the stage for a better organizational accident record moving forward.

Conclusions: Changing the nature of accident reviews in this way profoundly increased the trust within the ranks of the organization. The result was a reporting and learning culture within the Forest Service as a whole.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Joe Harris began his USDA Forest Service career in 1997. He started off in timber, and then in 1998 he moved over to fire. He has served on initial attack squads, engines, hotshot crews, fuels, fire management, and currently works for the Rocky Mountain Research Station specializing in accident investigations. He has a master’s degree from Lund University in Human Factors and Systems Safety and a PhD in Transdisciplinary Studies from the California Institute of Integral Studies.
Agenda Item Image
Dr Eric Maillé
Inrae-recover

OC73 - Territorial Vulnerability. Assessment using an expert opinion based multicriteria model.

Abstract

Objective

The objective is to develop a model for a relative assessment of territorial vulnerabilities to wildfire, to support local responsible in land management decision making. The aim is to compare the global vulnerability of local territories in order to prioritize correction actions on the most critical situations.

Methods

In order to assess territorial vulnerabilities, we used the multicriteria formalism and method. The formalism requires to organize the territorial stakes in a sematic hierarchy, ie. in classes and subclasses. A relative weigh is assigned to each stake classes and subclasses at the same level of a hierarchy. The weigh represents the importance of the stake class relatively to the others. Weight are assessed using analytical hierarchy processes applied to expert opinions individual judgments. Specific metrics were developed in order to properly take into account both the number of objects (class instances) and the dimension (size) of each object. The method was applied to the Baronnies Provençales Natural Regional Park.

Results

Results show a high variability of vulnerability level even on neighboring communes, due to high variations of stakes population of each classes. The specific vulnerability indexes allow to identify hot spot of vulnerability, mainly related to the person's related criteria (inhabitants, touristic accommodation sites, health infrastructures, etc.

Conclusion

Application of a multicriteria approach for territorial vulnerability assessment provide useful diagnosis in order for decision makers to anticipate the previewed future expansion. Some methodological questions, notably related to the quantification of the stakes dimension and population have still to be deepen.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Eric Maillé is a research ingeneer working on model specification for the assessment of the different components of wildland urban interface fire risk, at local scale. Among these components, vulnerability is one of his main concern. To do so, he uses different formalisms, including multicriteria evaluation and spatial analysis. He also develops dynamic models for simulation of change in fire risk level as a consequence of WUI change and land use/land cover change.
Agenda Item Image
Prof Renata Libonati
Ufrj

OC74 - Deforestation and agriculture drive Amazon fire activity, while droughts ride in the shotgun seat.

Abstract

The effects of land cover changes, compounded by the severe droughts of 2005 and 2010, pushed the Amazon Basin towards outstanding fire seasons. The record-breaking drought of 2015, exacerbated by El Niño, raised concerns about a fire season of unprecedented severity. However, using reliable remote sensing data, we show that fire activity in 2015 remained weak, at 54% and 44% of the levels attained in 2005 and 2010, and 25% below the average of the preceding 13 years. This contrast was enhanced when analyzing the energy released by persistent fires associated with deforestation activities, together with their spatial distribution. A principal component analysis yielded spatio-temporal patterns emphasizing that fire activity is higher, and the drought-fire relationship is stronger, when and where deforestation occurs. We then demonstrated that the overall decrease in deforestation rate was key to prevent the outbreak of biomass burning, despite the adverse meteorological conditions triggered by the outstanding drought of 2015. By dismissing the recently suggested decoupling between deforestation and fire activity driven by 21st century droughts, our results clearly show that the Amazon sensitivity to on-going shifts in anthropogenic pressure cannot be disregarded. The Amazon forest – still the largest tropical rainforest in the world – again is experiencing increasingly uncontrolled land occupation by agribusiness and mining interests, leading to increased deforestation rates. Therefore, ongoing undermining of environmental regulations and increased drought frequency projected by climate models are likely to bring large scale fire-disruption upon the Amazon ecosystem.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Dr. Libonati received her B.S. and Ph.D. degrees in geophysics from the University of Lisbon, in 2005 and 2011, respectively and is currently an Assistant Professor with the Department of Meteorology, UFRJ, and also part of the research team of the Forest Ecology Group - Institute of Agronomy and of the Instituto Dom Luiz, University of Lisbon. She is member of the WMO Expert Team on Climate Monitoring and Assessment . Her research activities focus on remote sensing of active fires and burned areas by satellite, the recovery of vegetation after large wildfires, the meteorological conditions associated to extreme events.
Agenda Item Image
Dr. Catrin Edgeley
Northern Arizona University

OC75 - How are residents’ evacuation decision-making processes affected by changing wildfire behavior? Investigating the 2020 East Troublesome Fire in Colorado, USA

Abstract

A growing body of research explores how fire behavior and related environmental conditions affect evacuation decision-making during wildfires. Understanding how fire behavior and human behavior interact can help improve evacuation models, develop more effective emergency communication, and support the design of evacuation plans that better reflect local social and ecological contexts, among other benefits. The objective of our research is to better characterize the role that extreme fire behavior plays in wildland-urban interface evacuation. To better understand the fire behavior-human behavior nexus, we conducted 35 interviews with 47 individuals affected by the East Troublesome Fire that burned in Grand County, Colorado USA during October 2020. This fire exhibited extreme behavior, which made it ideal for investigating how considerations such as wind speed and direction, smoke and broader air quality concerns, and the fire’s rate of spread, affected the timing and execution of decision-making related to evacuation. During the interviews, we introduced a series of 3D visualizations of the fire’s behavior and related weather conditions for October 21-22nd, the period when fire behavior and related social impacts from the fire were most intense. Visualizations were developed from fire and weather model data in partnership with the National Center for Atmospheric Research. We will present a timeline of the fire’s behavior paired with common behaviors that were triggered by each notable environmental cue. We conclude with recommendations for incorporating social responses to fire behavior into community hazard planning for risk reduction.

Supporting Documents / Presentations

Biography

Cat Edgeley is a wildfire social scientist interested in understanding how communities can better adapt to and recover from fires across diverse social and ecological contexts. She is an Assistant Professor in the School of Forestry at Northern Arizona University. Originally from the UK, Cat earned a BSc and MSc at Durham University before moving to the University of Idaho for her Ph.D.
loading